Omohundro Institute of Early American History & Culture

Leading Early American Scholarship Since 1943


Books

Unless otherwise indicated, all OI books are published and distributed by The University of North Carolina Press.


The Precisianist Strain

Disciplinary Religion and Antinomian Backlash in Puritanism to 1638

Theodore Bozeman

Cloth: 978-0-8078-2850-2 ($80.00)

Copyright 2004
University of North Carolina Press

Description

In an examination of transatlantic Puritanism from 1570 to 1638, Theodore Dwight Bozeman analyzes the quest for purity through sanctification. The word "Puritan," he says, accurately depicts a major and often obsessive trait of the English late Reformation: a hunger for discipline. The Precisianist Strain clarifies what Puritanism in its disciplinary mode meant for an early modern society struggling with problems of change, order, and identity.

Focusing on ascetic teachings and rites, which in their severity fostered the "precisianist strain" prevalent in Puritan thought and devotional practice, Bozeman traces the reactions of believers put under ever more meticulous demands. Sectarian theologies of ease and consolation soon formed in reaction to those demands, Bozeman argues, eventually giving rise to a "first wave" of antinomian revolt, including the American conflicts of 1636-1638. Antinomianism, based on the premise of salvation without strictness and duty, was not so much a radicalization of Puritan content as a backlash against the whole project of disciplinary religion. Its reconceptualization of self and responsibility would affect Anglo-American theology for decades to come.


About the Author

Theodore Dwight Bozeman is professor of religion at the University of Iowa. He is author of To Live Ancient Lives: The Primitivist Dimension in Puritanism and Protestants in an Age of Science: The Baconian Ideal and Antebellum American Religious


Reviews

Dwight Bozeman elaborates English Protestant devotional routine. . . . He argues forcefully for the various movements in England and New England termed ‘antinomianism’ to be seen as sustained protests against and deliberate alternatives to this great and defining Puritan achievement in practical divinity.

--Stephen Foster


Bozeman skillfully traces the origins of disciplinary exactitude as a hallmark of Puritanism. . . . By demonstrating how the Antinomian Controversy in Massachusetts derived from longstanding tensions among the godly in England, while feeding off unique local circumstances, he adds a new dimension to our understanding of Puritanism in its transatlantic context.

--Louise A. Breen


This book sets the rise of antinomianism in old and New England in the context of a full-scale reinterpretation of Puritanism from the 1570s to the 1640s. The range of reading is remarkably wide, the analysis and argument both precise and broad. The book contains many vignettes of startling insight. . . . A must-read for scholars and students of Puritanism on both sides of the Atlantic.

--Peter Lake


A rigorous and highly readable account. . . . A masterful exposition of Puritan religious history.

--The Journal of Religion


Bozeman's book is a mature work of scholarship that fulfills the potential of a previous seminal article and complements his earlier work.

--Historical Journal


This is a work of mature reflection based on a thoughtful and careful reading of many of the principal clerical sources.

--American Historical Review


Bozeman skillfully traces the origins of disciplinary exactitude as a hallmark of Puritanism. . . . By demonstrating how the Antinomian Controversy in Massachusetts derived from longstanding tensions among the godly in England, while feeding off unique local circumstances, he adds a new dimension to our understanding of Puritanism in its transatlantic context.

--Louise A. Breen, Kansas State University


[A] definitive exposition of the movement's biblical restoration. . . . A brilliant study. . . . Add[s] substantially to scholars' comprehension of the early seventeenth-century transatlantic Puritan movement.

--William and Mary Quarterly


[Bozeman's] consideration of the rise of English pietism significantly deepens our understanding of that school of Puritanism.

--Seventeenth Century News